Standing Out Means Standing for Something

I was honored to join a panel of fellow CEOs this past March at the University of Louisville’s School of Business to tackle the question on every advertiser’s mind: What impact will AI have on social media strategy?  

While AI gives those of us in the advertising industry many challenges and opportunities, there’s one specific area where brands need to focus first.  

‍

Strategy is Sacrifice

I don’t think anyone would disagree that a strong brand starts with strategy. But it’s one thing to talk about strategy, and another to actually live it. 

Although there is some debate about the source, David Ogilvy, a British ad man known as the “Father of Advertising,” is often credited with the phrase, “The essence of strategy is sacrifice.” Even if it isn’t a quote from Ogilvy, it’s still a powerful statement.

As much as we all wish there was a magic formula to make a brand appeal to everyone, the simple truth is that no brand can be everything to everyone.

Brand differentiation requires choosing who you're for, and who you’re not for. Because if you don’t make that choice, someone else will make it for you. Your competitors, your audience, or the algorithms.

Leading a full-service advertising agency, I’ve watched the rules for brand differentiation in online advertising change several times. And they’re changing again.

‍

The Cycle of Digital Marketing

Social platforms tend to move through predictable phases. They start human, become commercial, then audiences want something human again.

Early social media was very human. You could be your real self online and find a community of other people like you. Then in 2012, everything changed when Facebook launched mobile advertising. Suddenly advertisers had targeting capabilities that had never existed before. Marketers could reach incredibly specific audiences with precision.

For brands, it felt like magic.

Over time, however, the platform became more commercial. Ads increased. Feeds felt less personal. And audiences began migrating toward new environments, specifically short-form video platforms like Snapchat and TikTok.

These platforms felt human again. People shared real moments, personality-driven content, and raw creativity. This led directly to the creator economy, where creators became the trust layer between brands and audiences. The strongest brands not only began working directly with creators, but they differentiated their ads with compelling, targeted creative.

Now we are entering another major shift.

‍

AI is Changing the Game (Again)

Generative AI is accelerating everything. LLMs like ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini can write your copy, design your ads, and build your website. And on top of all that, platforms like Meta can automate targeting even more.

This creates huge opportunities for brands. You can generate huge amounts of creative content and trust the algorithms to find an audience. But it also introduces a huge challenge:

How do you build trust and authentic human connection in a world where any content can be generated instantly, and at a massive scale?

The answer is strategy.

‍

Winning Takes More Than Speed and Scale

Here's the reality: the future doesn't belong to brands that automate everything.

It belongs to brands that know what they stand for. Brands that know who they are talking to and what they are saying before they scale. Brands that use AI to amplify clear, strategic stories.

AI is a tool. A powerful one. It can produce huge amounts of content. But it can’t make decisions about what the right content is for your audience. Only human thinking can do that.

‍

What Happens Without Strategic Clarity

One of our clients serves as a great example. 

Their research showed that 87% of consumers recognized their logo. On paper, that sounds like strong brand awareness.

But when you asked people what the brand actually was, most couldn't explain it. Recognition is not the same thing as awareness. Or understanding.

We could easily amplify the brand on social media ad platforms. But with a brand that lacks clarity, that wouldn’t help them at all. It would only create noise at scale.

So we took our client through our PathFinder Workshop. Our process helped them clarify who their audience was and what they were looking for so we could shift their brand strategy and messaging.  

Once the story became clear:

• The creative improved
• The messaging sharpened
• Campaigns dramatically outperformed previous campaigns

‍

Chart the Course Before Launch

At RedTag, our entire process is built around discovering and defining strategy first.

That's how the PathFinder Workshop was born: it’s a deliberate first step we take with every engagement before a single piece of creative is produced or a dollar of media is spent.

Instead of jumping directly into execution, we first help organizations define:

• Their brand positioning
• Their core audience
• The story they want to tell

Strategy informs everything else that comes after.

‍

What Now?

If you want to build something that lasts, whether it’s a brand, a campaign, or even a career, you need to:

• Define who and what you are for
• Build for your audience and story
• Move forward only on what matters

AI is changing everything, and the flood of noise it’s creating on our feeds is just starting. The strongest brands will be the ones willing to sacrifice all the noise and give everything to the one strategic signal that will move their audience.

Don’t add to the noise. Make your signal stronger. 

Explore the PathFinder Workshop

‍